 |
Earth Liberation Front suspect charged in
California SUV arson, vandalism raids -
Center for the Defense of Free Enterprise
Executive Vice President Ron Arnold today
congratulated the FBI for the March 9 arrest
of the first of two ecoterror suspects in a
week—Michael Scarpitti was arrested March 13.
Arnold has been retained as expert consultant
on ecoterrorism for a major study at the
University of Arkansas Terrorism Research
Center, funded by a grant from the National
Institute of Justice (NIJ). William Jensen
"Billy" Cottrell, a 23-year-old graduate
physics student from Pasadena, was indicted
for damaging or destroying 125 sport utility
vehicles at car dealerships and homes in the
Los Angeles area last August, said Thom Mrozek,
a spokesman for the U.S. attorney's office on
Wednesday. |
 |
Autoterrorist Arrested for SUV
Vandalism in Los Angeles
-
A California
Institute of Technology graduate student has
been arrested in connection with an August
arson and vandalism spree targeting 125 sports
utility vehicles at four car dealerships, the
FBI said. William Cottrell, 23, used an alias
when he e-mailed The Los Angeles Times,
claiming to be a member of the eco-terrorist
group Earth Liberation Front and offering
specific details to prove his involvement in
the fire bombings, the FBI said.
|
 |
WILLIAM JENSEN COTTRELL, February 2003
Indictment
 |
 |
Arrest
Affidavit  |
 |
SUV Vandalism Suspect Denied Bail Again /
If Convicted On All Accounts, Faces 70 Years
In Prison. -
A judge
Wednesday refused bail a second time for a
Caltech grad student charged in connection
with the fire bombings and vandalism of SUVs
at San Gabriel Valley dealerships. , by KCLA9
- Los Angeles |
 |
Cottrell
attorney says client tried to stop vandalism
- A defense lawyer for alleged ecoterrorist
Billy Cottrell gave a preview of the Caltech
graduate student's anticipated testimony
during opening statements Tuesday in U.S.
District Court.
Attorney Michael Mayock told jurors that
Cottrell was "shocked' when alleged
co-conspirator Tyler Johnson set fire to a
sport utility vehicle and then tried to talk
Johnson out of continuing. "This is bad,'
Mayock said, paraphrasing what he claims
Cottrell told Johnson. "You can't do this.
This is a mistake.' |
 |
Alleged Eco-Terrorist to Stand Trial on
October 26; On October 26; Press
Conference Following Hearing, October 12, 2004
- Since his arrest in early March, William
Billy Cottrell has been held in questionable
conditions, all the while maintaining his
innocence and steadfastly disputing
allegations that he is or has ever been a
member of the Earth Liberation Front (ELF). On
March 9, Cottrell was arrested in conjunction
with a series of alleged ELF arsons involving
southland SUV dealerships. Cottrell, a 24 year
old Caltech PhD student, is currently being
held without bail at the Metropolitan
Detention Center in downtown Los Angeles.
There he awaits trial on nine counts stemming
from the August 22, 2003 arsons. / Press
Release |
 |
Billy Cottrell's Jury selection started today
- Jury selection is scheduled to start today
in the trial of a Caltech grad student accused
of firebombing sport utility vehicles in the
San Gabriel Valley, causing millions of
dollars in damage. |
 |
Billy Cottrell trial delayed -
The case against Billy Cottrell has taken a
new twist. During the summer of 2004 the
Prosecution told Billy they intended to bring
multiple 924c "use of a destructive device
during a violent crime" charges against him.
Each charge carries a mandatory minimum of 30
years imprisonment which can not be served
concurrently with any other charge. So if a
person is found guilty of one of these charge
its a minimum 30 year sentence. Two charges, a
minimum 60 year sentence. Three charges, a
minimum 90 year sentence. Etc. The reason for
the threat was clear, the Prosecution believe
that Billy has information about the Earth
Liberation Front and wanted to apply pressure
to get him talking and start naming names. To
really emphasize their desire to get Billy to
talk the Prosecution told Billy that because
of the new charges they may call for a minimum
sentence of "Life imprisonment without the
possibility of parole". However, up until this
week the new charges did not materialize. Then
things started going against the Prosecution. |
 |
Cottrell goes on trial this week -
According to the government's trial memo, the
case against Caltech grad student Billy
Cottrell scheduled to begin Tuesday is fairly
straightforward. Cottrell, 24, and two
friends, Tyler Johnson and Michie Oe, got
together Aug. 22, 2003. They allegedly went to
a Pasadena gas station and loaded up detergent
bottles with gasoline, for use in making
Molotov cocktails, by Gene Maddaus |
 |
Lawyers for student charged in SUV arson hope
to focus on mental state -
Lawyers for a
graduate student indicted in a series of fire
bombings and vandalizing of sport utility
vehicles hope to use his mental state as a
defense during trial by NapaNews.com |
 |
Cottrell's mental state at issue
- "Five months later, the two defense
attorneys have filed notice that they do intend to make an issue of
Cottrell's mental state. The attorneys announced last week that a defense
expert has diagnosed Cottrell with Asperger's syndrome, also known as
"high-functioning autism.' Those who have Asperger's, the
attorneys say, have a hard time functioning socially, tend to take things
too literally and are also prone to bouts of confusion. They are often also
uncommonly bright, and can focus on particular problems much longer than
those who don't have the illness," by
Gene Maddaus |
 |
Man charged with bombing to
claim mental defect
/
A man charged
with firebombing sport utility vehicles at San
Gabriel Valley dealerships will present a
mental-defect defense and claim he has
Asperger's syndrome. Asperger's syndrome is a
type of autism where an individual can display
eccentric behavior but often has high
intelligence and language skills. U.S.
District Judge Gary Klausner on Tuesday denied
a prosecution request to postpone the Oct. 26
trial so a government expert could interview
defendant William Cottrell about his mental
health. |
 |
Alleged 'fugitive coconspirators' identified in San Gabriel Valley arson
spree - "...Cottrell faces 35 years to life in prison if
convicted of burning and spray-painting SUVs during the environmental
vandalism spree. Cottrell's defense lawyers will present a mental-defect
defense during trial, claiming he has Asperger's syndrome. Asperger's
syndrome is a type of autism where an individual can display eccentric
behavior but often has normal language skills and high intelligence by the
Associated Press |
 |
Prosecutors seek delay in Cottrell case - Prosecutors are seeking a
delay in the case of alleged Caltech ecoterrorist Bill Cottrell, insisting
they need more time to research a defense claim that Cottrell suffers from
a form of autism known as Asperger's Syndrome. Cottrell's defense filed a
motion Wednesday objecting to the delay and asking that the trial proceed
as scheduled Oct. 26 by Gene Maddaus |
 |
Judge OKs delay in SUV vandalism trial / A judge agreed Monday to a
prosecution request for a two-week delay in the trial of alleged
eco-terrorist Bill Cottrell.
The trial, which had been scheduled to start next week, will now begin
Nov. 9, Judge Gary Klausner said. Prosecutors said they still need more
time to do an independent psychological analysis of Cottrell. The Caltech
graduate student is accused of torching and spray-painting more than 125
sport utility vehicles in the San Gabriel Valley in August 2003 by Gene
Maddaus |
 |
Judge refuses to delay SUV vandalism trial /
Prosecutors sought 3 months to evaluate
Cottrell - Lawyers for alleged eco-terrorist Bill Cottrell won a victory
Tuesday when a federal judge refused to grant prosecutors more time to
prepare for trial. Judge Gary Klausner denied a prosecution request to
delay the trial at least until January to allow time for a government
expert to evaluate Cottrell, a physics grad student at Caltech, for signs
of Asperger's Syndrome by Gene Maddaus |
 |
The Physicist and
the Torched SUVs - Nov. 1 issue - Could a little-understood mental
disorder called Asperger's syndrome clear Billy Cottrell of ecoterrorism
charges? Cottrell, 24, is a brilliant but quirky physics grad student at
the California Institute of Technology who faces trial in Los Angeles on
federal arson counts that may send him to prison for life. Prosecutors
charge that he and two unnamed conspirators torched 14 Hummers and a
building during an Aug. 22, 2003, spree in which 125 SUVs worth $3.5
million were burned or spray-painted with slogans like SUV = TERRORISM.
The vandals claimed responsibility in the name of the Earth Liberation
Front, a shadowy group that says it has destroyed property worth more than
$100 million nationwide. In a statement, Cottrell, who pleaded not guilty,
said he never committed arson, but he hasn't denied being present that
night. His lawyers hope to explain the apparent contradiction by showing
that Cottrell has Asperger's syndrome, a mild form of autism marked by an
impaired ability to comprehend social situations. "The question is: how
can somebody so smart be so dumb?" says his attorney Marvin Rudnick. "And
Asperger's answers that question." - News Week |
 |
Judge deals Cottrell setback - A federal
judge barred any further discussion of Asperger's syndrome Friday in the
ecoterrorism trial of Caltech grad student Billy Cottrell. Judge Gary
Klausner ruled the condition, a form of autism, is irrelevant to the
question of whether Cottrell conspired to set fire to sport utility vehicles
in August 2003. Cottrell faces 35 years to life in prison if convicted of
setting fire to several SUVs and a West Covina Hummer dealership in August
2003. More than 125 SUVs in four San Gabriel Valley cities were either
burned or tagged with environmentalist graffiti. Friday's ruling was a
setback for the defense, which argued in opening statements the condition
made Cottrell an easy dupe, and he was unable to extricate himself from the
conspiracy once it began. Those who have Asperger's syndrome typically have
difficulty interpreting social situations by
Gene Maddaus |
 |
Judge blocks autism defense in SoCal SUV arson case
- A
judge on Friday barred attorneys defending a graduate student charged in an
arson spree of sport utility vehicles from presenting evidence he suffered
from a type of autism known as Asperger's syndrome. Lawyers said in court
earlier in the week that William Jensen Cottrell, 24, thought he was going
with two friends to only graffiti the vehicles and was surprised when they
began hurling Molotov cocktails instead. Attorneys claimed Cottrell's
medical condition made it difficult for him to understand the intentions of
his alleged accomplices and an "easy dupe," by the Associated Press |
 |
Connole may take stand in SUV case -
"...The 26-year-old antiwar activist was
arrested in 2003 on suspicion of torching and
vandalizing sport utility vehicles in West
Covina and other San Gabriel Valley cities --
then later released without charges being
filed against him. He said he has received a
subpoena to testify on behalf of the current
suspect standing trial, Billy Cottrell.
..."They are not related in that way. As I
understand the Cottrell defense, they do not
contest he was there. Their defense was he has
this Asperger's syndrome (a high-functioning
autism that prevents those who have it from
accurately reading social situations) and not
criminally responsible for what is going on." |
 |
Autism defense rejected in case
of SUV arson
-
A judge on
Friday barred attorneys defending a graduate
student charged in an arson spree of sport
utility vehicles from presenting evidence he
suffered from a type of autism known as
Asperger's syndrome. Lawyers said in court
earlier in the week that William Jensen
Cottrell, 24, thought he was going with two
friends to only graffiti the vehicles and was
surprised when they began hurling Molotov
cocktails instead. Attorneys claimed
Cottrell's medical condition made it difficult
for him to understand the intentions of his
alleged accomplices and an ''easy dupe.'' But
U.S. District Judge Gary Klausner ruled Friday
that the condition could not be used as part
of Cottrell's defense. |
 |
William Cottrell's "I Couldn't Help it
Defense" - Commentary from Animal Crackers
/ This website is covering the trial and has
several commentaries. |
 |
Arson suspect claims he painted
SUVs but didn't set them on fire
- A graduate physics student told jurors on
Wednesday that he spray-painted the initials
of the Earth Liberation Front on a string of
sport utility vehicles as part of a vandalism
spree last year, but that he did not set any
vehicles ablaze by
Copley
News Service |
 |
Man denies he set fires to SUVs in vandalism
spree -
A graduate physics student told jurors
yesterday that he spray-painted the initials
of the Earth Liberation Front on a string of
sport utility vehicles as part of a vandalism
spree last year, but didn't set any ablaze by
Matt Krasnowski |
 |
Cottrell testifies in own defense / Suspect in
SUV vandalism case denies he committed arson
- Caltech SUV-vandalism suspect Billy Cottrell
testified in his own defense Wednesday,
denying he committed arson but admitting he
believed environmental graffiti to be morally
justified because SUV dealerships are "evil.'
Cottrell said the sport utility vehicle fires
of August 2003 were the work of two fugitives,
Michie Oe and Tyler Johnson, and that he knew
nothing of the arson plot beforehand, by Gene
Maddaus |
 |
Judge rejects bid for new trial by convicted arsonist - A federal judge
turned away a request Monday for a new trial for a graduate student
convicted last year of firebombing scores of sport utility vehicles in a
vandalism rampage that caused more than $2 million in damage. The
motion by William Jensen Cottrell was rejected by U.S. District Judge R.
Gary Klausner after a brief hearing, said Thom Mrozek, a spokesman for the
U.S. attorney's office in Los Angeles. Cottrell sought a new trial
claiming, among other issues, that the court improperly barred his attorneys
from presenting evidence that he suffered from a type of autism known as
Asperger's syndrome. His attorneys claimed the medical condition made it
difficult for him to understand the intentions of his alleged accomplices,
by the AP |